On board a Gulam Express of the Indian Railways

Away from the cool coaches of the Vande Bharat trains with their electric blue seats, wide clear glass panels and LCD screens showing government promos, there exist what you could call Gulam Express trains. These are the hundreds of trains that are superfast, but also obsolete for the BJP government and the upper middle classes now. It is these trains that continue to transport millions of GDP-producing workers across India, now the most populous country in the world, not your VBs.

By sheer accident, this writer could get a taste of a Gulam Express (translating into slave Express – perhaps it should be Vande Gulam Express), on the overnight stretch between Ernakulam and Chennai Perambur on May 4. The train is officially named Shalimar Express and bears the number 22641. Since it covers Chennai, Andhra Pradesh, Odisha and West Bengal en route Kolkata, it attracts a large number of travellers, most of them workers from Bengal who have been toiling in manual jobs in the south.

People are forced to travel like this to Odisha, Bengal and beyond. Shalimar Express, May 4, 2024, reserved S1 coach.

On many such Gulam Expresses, it matters little that the berths are reserved in advance by passengers. There are simply far too many people who want to get home from the south to the east and the northeast, and the number of seats available is a fraction of this count. The situation challenges the government.

An unusual solution

The Indian Railways has come up with an ingenious solution: all those who want to travel in the reserved bogies can pay a fine of Rs.500 per head, get a receipt, with no further trouble during the rest of the journey by the same coach! No upper limit on passengers. After all, when you have paid the railways, even as a penalty, are you not entitled to travel? Of course, a coach can only accommodate some 75 people by design, but the Railways initiative pushes up that number to two or three times that figure.

The TTEs issue Rs.500 penalty tickets to everyone without proper ticket in the coach, and they can then remain in the carriage.

And so it was in coach S1, where the TTEs from Kerala ensured that everyone paid the Rs.500 and got their receipt, watched by a well-built railway policeman. A Tamil Nadu TTE did the same after Erode. All the worker-travellers were ready with the money, since this gulami (slavish) experience apparently is now well entrenched.

Many berths were quickly occupied by these passengers and they turned their attention to music videos, video calls and other distractions. The train attracted a fresh set of workers in Thrissur, and they too squeezed themselves in. More joined in Coimbatore, Erode, Salem and Katpadi. No one was getting off, only more were “entraining”, as the railways likes to say it.

Prepared for the long haul of two nights and several hours on board, from Thiruvananthapuram in Kerala to Shalimar (Shibpur-Howrah) in Bengal. May 4, 2024.

Some of the younger passengers readjusted the luggage underneath the lower berths, and wedged themselves into that space (picture). Somehow, this brings up images of slaves transported to America by ship in another age. If India is the world’s fastest growing economy, there’s little sign of it in these trains. There were no quarrels, no arguments among the people travelling. They found spaces in the carriage, much like water finds its level. After a while, some of the workers lit up beedis, the smoke wafting through the carriage to everyone. Some women passengers simply lay turning their backs to the vastly male-dominated group of passengers. Many more were sitting in the aisles.

Transgender people extort

There was a nasty little surprise in store for some of the passengers. A group of 20 transgender persons forced their way into the carriage at Erode. These well-built, sari-clad, male-voiced individuals were in no mood for refusals at 3 a.m., and they went about their business extorting petty cash from the workers with the niceties of street thugs.

“Kick the bast**ds out of the way,” said one of the group leaders in Tamil, using the expletive for s.o.b liberally, perhaps aware that the quarry could not follow what was being said. “Motherf**kers!” one from the group screamed, to overcome the weak resistance.

One of the transwomen grabbed a youth who was trying to get some sleep by his clothes and pulled up his head. “Give,” she ordered. “Show him what you have,” another transwoman was heard shouting. “These chaps should be buggered,” said another, all expletives in Tamil.

No one raised any protest. The trans folk were actually heavily outnumbered by the workers, and logically, were sitting ducks for a thrashing. But that did not happen, possibly because the workers did not want a run-in with the law in an alien State.

Most workers just dug into their pockets and paid ten or twenty. The demands were repeated an hour later to cover new passengers, this time the trans people asking for “one or two rupees”. Evidently, TTEs, Railway Protection Force/Government Railway Police made no move to restrain the trans people, who were presumably ticketless, from boarding a train at the unearthly hour of 3 a.m.

In India, you learn to live like a slave, squeezing yourself under the lower berth to spend the night.

Mondal (name changed) from Siliguri seemed not to be fazed by all the commotion and the difficulty of people having to stretch out in the aisles and the berth bays. “I am going back after 3 years of working in Kerala,” the youth said, asserting that he would not return.

Although there was a mass of humanity in the aisle, IRCTC catering attendants shouting “chai, chai” picked their way through the contorted bodies on the floor, hands, feet and heads pointing in different angles. If you could get to a bathroom similarly picking your way, you would find it filthy and unusable.

In today’s India, it is better to live furtively, endure a slave-like journey and get home in one piece, rather than risk the wrath of the state. Life possessions of the workers to take back home had been packed into paint drums, plastic sacks and dirty rexine bags. The paint drums are durable and cheap replacements for suitcases. If it is any solace, most of these workers from the east and northeast possessed smartphones.

As daylight broke around 5.30 a.m., many again picked their way through the mass of sleeping comrades to brush their teeth. The IRCTC people arrived with samosas, bread omelettes and channa for sale, along with tea. Even in the heaving mass, one has to eat to get ready for a roiling day ahead in Andhra Pradesh en route home in Bengal.

Unchanged over a century

The scenes on the Gulam Express trains evoke parts of Mahatma Gandhi’s record of his own travels in “Third Class in Indian Railways” (Ranchi, September 25, 1917). In one passage, he says, “A defiant Memon merchant protested against this packing of passengers like sardines [in a train]. In vain did he say that this was his fifth night on the train. The guard insulted him and referred him to the management at the terminus. There were during this night as many as 35 passengers in the carriage during the greater part of it. Some lay on the floor in the midst of dirt and some had to keep standing. A free fight was, at one time, avoided only by the intervention of some of the older passengers who did not want to add to the discomfort by an exhibition of temper.” This was long before Amrit Kaal began.

Not every train is a Vande Bharat. In fact, most trains are like this one even in reserved sleeper coaches, thanks to the present Railway policy. Shalimar Express, May 4, 2024.

As with a lot of other things in India, the quintessential train ride remains unchanged. Some trains do provide the comfort of sleeper class seats without such crowding. But not to the north and east. World-leading GDP growth, high profile train inaugurations, vast outlays for station modernisation and the presence of computers and smartphones has not added enough seats or berths.

Shashi Tharoor lamented that people were relegated to cattle class in air travel in 2009. Quite valid then, to see the plight of the workers and others in the Indian sleeper class and second class train coaches as a neo-slave class. These people must pay up, and stuff themselves into the carriage to go home. They cannot go to the toilet easily and must encounter filth there. While sweating through such rides, these miserable travellers can only let their imagination run wild on how they would one day ride expensive Bullet Trains, the first of which is to run between Mumbai and Ahmedabad in a 508 km segment at an unspecified date, and which is the only political priority now.

Vande Bharat a.k.a Train 18 and its troubled history – a media repository

Every new Vande Bharat train launch makes it appear to be a signal achievement of the ruling BJP and Prime Minister Narendra Modi. It is actually an achievement of the Integral Coach Factory (ICF) and railway engineers.

The truth about the train is not widely discussed today. As the following newspaper reports and media articles make clear, VB or Train 18 as it was known at its first launch, was indirectly opposed by the present Union government. Rather than try to facilitate it, many spokes were put in its progress.

The stories below are from The Hindu, The India Forum and EconomicTimes.

Train 18: All about India’s first indigenously-built, engine-less train: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/transportation/railways/train-18-all-about-indias-first-indigenously-built-engine-less-train/videoshow/66377803.cms?from=mdr

Train 18 and Before: Indigenous High Technology Research in India https://www.theindiaforum.in/article/train-18-and

Weight issue halted Train 18 construction – Railway Board: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/weight-issue-halted-train18-construction-railway-board/article30228849.ece

Architect of Train 18 shifted to less prominent post: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/architect-of-train18-shifted-to-low-ranking-post/article32627308.ece

Train18 officer not in Railways promotions list: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/train18-officer-not-in-promotion-list/article32589954.ece

Production of Vande Bharat trains comes to a grinding halt: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/production-of-vande-bharat-express-comes-to-a-grinding-halt/article28313228.ece

ICF team of Train 18 comes under vigilance scanner: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/icf-team-of-train18-comes-under-vigilance-scanner/article30121187.ece

CVC drops action against top officials of Train 18 team: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/cvc-drops-action-against-top-railways-officials/article32613114.ece

New Vande Bharat trains to be faster, safer: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/new-vande-bharat-trains-to-be-faster-safer/article30375262.ece

Withdraw the Digital Personal Data Protection Bill 2022 move

Dec 16, 2022

I am writing to oppose the proposed Digital Personal Data Protection Bill 2022, of the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, because it contains provisions that threaten fundamental rights flowing from the Right to Information, a right essential to accessing other fundamental rights, including the right to life guaranteed by the Constitution of India.

The proposed elimination of a well-considered provision in the Right to Information Act, 2005, which is to interpret personal information from the point of public interest, is a negation of the very basis of the RTI. The RTI Act is the product of extensive consultations and consideration, and it has incorporated the careful and nuanced distinction of whether the information sought is a matter of public interest, and its proviso states clearly that information that would be presented to Parliament and legislatures cannot be denied to the citizen.

Public activity, public interest and personal information pertaining to public duties cannot be classified as an unwarranted intrusion into privacy. Moreover, as included in the law on defamation, only activity that pertains to the private life and activities of the individual which has no bearing on public duties can be exempt.

By seeking to completely eliminate the carefully considered material portion of Sec. 8 (1) (j) of the Right to Information Act, including its proviso which protects the right and places it on par with the rights of members of legislatures and Parliament, the proposed Digital Personal Data Protection Bill 2022 strikes at the heart of a hard-won freedom of the citizen and deserves to be opposed completely.

By rendering all private information inaccessible, even when it is vital to the survival and good health of the larger community – such as identities of who has been issued welfare benefits in a particular area, information needed to ensure delivery of such benefits including public distribution system materials and pensions – the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology seeks to sharply curtail social audit of welfare measures. This is a dangerous, unjustifiable. It is equally perverse to say that all data gathered places a fiduciary responsibility since this threatens even community data collection, academic activity and research.

The right of the citizen to free and full information is sacrosanct, recognised by the Supreme Court, enshrined in international covenants as a human right, and an invaluable tool to press for transparent democratic governance. I vehemently oppose any measure to amend the Right to Information Act, 2005 through the backdoor.

G. Ananthakrishnan / Chennai / submitted online to the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, Government of India

Tamil Nadu, Chennai and urbanisation: some critical perspectives

India’s urbanisation trajectory is still in the lower realms, with much of the infrastructure yet to be built. This is also a time when business and special interests are quietly working to influence the course of urban planning, creating lock-in effects for facilities being planned or built – public buildings, energy, parks and playgrounds, mobility systems such as trains, bus systems and non-motorised transport.

I have a close connection to the urban form, and try to analyse the directions of such planning.

Here are some links to recent articles that I have written on these topics.

How flyovers create more problems than they solve

Looking at nature in cities, this time at butterflies: The lives of butterflies of Tamil Nadu – from tiger reserves to city parks

The DMK government in Tamil Nadu proposes to raise property taxes and other service fees. But it cannot be business as usual on civic governance. Responsive civic governments can pull off higher property taxes

In this article, I look at the poor outcomes of the Miyawaki method of greening the city, since it sharply diverges from the natural course of tree growth. Why sacred groves will work better than Miyawaki forests to make Chennai green

My earlier columns in The Hindu can be accessed here: https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/chennai//article54691585.ece

The direction of urbanisation depends crucially on citizen participation. Make your voice heard with your local body representatives, MLAs, MPs and civic agencies to make the future of India’s cities people-friendly!

Khadi, high fashion with Kamal’s KH House of Khaddar

My recent article on https://inmathi.com/ dwells on the rise and rise of khadi or khaddar, the Gandhian fabric of India’s independence, and its present footprint as the cloth of designer fabrics launched by Kamal Haasan’s KH House of Khaddar house. You can read that here.

Earlier, I wrote in the same online magazine on the Manjappai campaign of the Tamil Nadu government, taking a close look at what really goes into a genuine ‘yellow bag’. I spoke to the entrepreneurs such as Krishnan Subramanian who is based in Madurai and J. Kughanandam, Gandhi and Sarvodaya-inspired entrepreneur whose venture, Geo Care Products in Chennai, turns many forms of waste into new material. That post on the return of the Manjappai is here: https://inmathi.com/2021/12/25/meendum-manjappai-a-classic-returns/35305/ The present situation is that there are not enough cotton bags available. There is also little public discussion on the way forward, although this initiative was launched with fanfare by Chief Minister M.K. Stalin. Meanwhile, plastic use and plastic waste continue to grow as an environmental challenge.

Cities on the frontline against Diabetes – C40 Cities Mayors Summit 2019

“A group of experts and mayors from selected and potential new partnership cities in the global Cities Changing Diabetes are invited to a roundtable discussion on how cities can be designed to be more sustainable and climate-friendly and at the same time fight the continuously growing threat of diabetes and related chronic diseases.” – This is part of the ongoing C40 Cities World Mayors Summit agenda, and something our own policymakers and media should be looking at.

Indian cities are heavily polluted, people are forced to eat junk calories and vehicle-dependence is overwhelming. In short, this should be session for Indian politicians. Sadly, most of them can see, hear and eat only money!

See the full session at the C40 here:

FT expose on Israel’s NSO raises questions on Pegasus use in India

This investigative piece published by the Financial Times (requires subscription) shows that Israel has been backing one of its companies, NSO, in selling clandestine software that is injected into phones via WhatsApp to track everything that the phone does and contains. The software also targets cloud services of Apple, Google, Facebook, Amazon, Microsoft and so on.

Is the Narendra Modi government also a client of the company, NSO? Did it buy the Pegasus software that Saudi Arabia and others have bought? If yes, for what? Questions must be raised in Parliament on this. Hostile forces can also track Indian politicians, making a mockery of our hyper-secretive establishment.

FT reports that WhatsApp, which is owned by Facebook, is still investigating the scale of the penetration by the Israeli spyware. It began rolling out a fix for servers last Friday.

Although Pegasus is sold ostensibly to help governments fight terrorism and crime, it has been found on the phone of dissidents and critics in different countries such as Saudi Arabia and Mexico. That includes a friend of murdered Saudi dissident Kamal Khashoggi and the wife of a Mexican journalist who was also killed.

How many Indians are affected by the breach of WhatsApp, and potentially the cloud services? The Indian government needs to answer.

Motor Vehicles Act amendments revived: Why have States given Centre the advantage?

The NDA govt. has revived the Motor Vehicles Amendment Bill in the LS, introducing the proposed changes on July 15.
I am not a votary of States being dictated to by the Centre, but equally, I cannot agree with States maintaining status quo in transport when our economic development and need for new jobs requires an entirely new transport framework. New schemes to encourage small entrepreneurs are needed, on the lines of small retailing is encouraged against giant retailers, and technological modernisation is urgently called for to improve utilisation of investments and aid passengers with information.
The interesting thing is that as per the amendments, the Centre will have powers to make schemes for multi-modal transport, among other things, and to aid mobility and use of transport assets, including through last mile connectivity. This was part of the lapsed Bill too in the earlier NDA regime that has now been revived.
Then again, this requirement is something that State governments have been consistently ignoring, in favour of the expensive Ubers and the Olas. They have stifled growth and instead adopted a narrow view of distributing patronage through unregulated schemes like share autos that are allowed to cannibalise bus routes rather than being asked to serve interior areas of cities as last mile carriages. Don’t get me wrong, I am not against share autos, but I want freedom for anyone to operate a share auto as a feeder carriage, with a licence, not just those who are affiliated to some organisation or other. If encouraging small entrepreneurs is your goal, make it open to all those who are likely to benefit.

img_20190425_183008

Government Estate Metro Station, Chennai. Metro Rail systems have failed to take off in the absence of last-mile connectivity.

Technically, the State governments can also make their own new schemes even now, before the amendments, to aid the above objectives, but this sector has fallen victim to corrupt policy. The traditional public sector operators have been underfunded and prevented from becoming truly modern. Many do not have professional management. So we have bus systems increasingly confined to arterial roads, as in Chennai, and have stopped serving residential communities. I am waiting to see how the MV Act amendments fare.
We badly need a shake-up of policy that will enable expansion of public transport. If the State governments see the writing on the wall, they will work to close the gap by introducing their own schemes even now, preferably using well-run public sector networks, for which they are fully empowered.

EPS95 pensioners launch struggle to secure pension on full salary

The Employees Pension Scheme 95 (EPS95) run by the Provident Fund is applicable to employees who made contributions between 1995 and 2014 to this scheme.

The pension contributions were made on a salary ceiling of Rs.6,500 earlier, from out of the employer’s PF contribution.

In 1996, an option was made for employees to contribute on their actual salary, rather than on the limited ceiling amount above, which in any case provided only a meagre pension. Since this was not communicated to employees, no one knew about it, and hardly anyone opted for it. It required a joint option with the employer also, which would have been difficult without the employer’s backing.

In 2014, the EPFO was asked to close this option with a 6 month deadline from September 1, 2014, by which employees had to opt for the contribution on full salary, again with a joint option with employer. This was also not communicated to anyone, and the office also did not make this offer known. If one did not opt in, one is deemed to have opted out of the scheme, although no one knew it existed in the first place.

The EPF authorities in the regions are now refusing to accept claims for pension on full salary [where employees are ready to pay the
difference amount for contribution out of their own funds] citing the time limitation.

However, in 2015, a set of employees led by R C Gupta went to the Supreme Court and got an order in their favour, in which the court observed that there was no limitation envisaged in the PF pension scheme, and the six month deadline was arbitrary.

Against this backdrop, fresh claims are being made to EPFO, to include employees and retirees, for pension on full salary, where they will pay the difference in contribution to the PF Organisation.

A Public Notice was put out by EPFO in The Tribune in Chandigarh, on January 25, 2018, in pursuance of Supreme Court orders in SLP No. 33032 and 33033 of 2015 regarding revision of pension.

Today, EPFO is rejecting claims for inclusion, stating that it is not possible to opt for the full pension because members did not exercise the option before the 2014-15 deadline.

But Clause (ii) of the notice published in the Tribune indicates that members of EPS-95 are eligible for pension on full salary, if they pay the difference between what was remitted under wage ceiling, and amount to be remitted under full salary along with interest. This notice is in pursuance of a case that was decided, rejecting the very limitation that the EPFO continues to cite.

Politically, this is a sensitive issue for the Narendra Modi-led government because a lot of pensioners are litigating for relief in various courts, including the Supreme Court, against the arbitrariness of the government’s move. The Opposition parties including the Congress, CPI (M), Trinamool, DMK, CPI are yet to take it up.

The struggle is harder for members of exempted establishments, since their scheme was administered not by EPFO, but by a Trust.

One resource person on the issue is Praveen Kohli (pkkohli) (phone: +919810306699) who is in Gurugram.

He has won his case and has launched a Facebook drive to bring all aggrieved persons together, and has a membership of close to 42,000 and growing.